[Solved] Warrior Can't Protect Teammates

One of my students, who is a warrior, tries to protect his team mates via "Deal with damage later" que.  He is unable to do this if he also has damage pending because his name starts with an A which puts him at the top of the list.  It will not allow him to click on anyone beneath his name which means he can never protect anyone unless he does it right when the damage happens.  I rarely apply the damage on the spot because it interrupts the flow of my classroom and would rather let them do it later during "Classcraft character time."  Please help!